PHILLIPSBURG RIVERVIEW ORGANIZATION (PRO)

HARMONY PROJECTS COMMITTEE
68 S. Main St. Phillipsburg, NJ

phone and fax: 908-454-4141

Sent: 11 May '07 16:42


Mr Larry Baier, Director
Watershed Management, NJDEP

Re: block 35 and lot 1, Harmony Township

Dear Mr Baier:

I am writing in response to the written decision of the NJDEP denying recognition of a C-1 tributary to the Buckhorn
Creek issued March 27, 2007 at the above identified property.

The NJDEP storm water management regulation (7:8-5.5) specifically mandates only two choices "waters as shown on
the USGS Quadrangle Maps or in the County Soil Surveys". Please note the word "or"; one or the other source. It does
NOT give a developer the option to substitute an alternative method or the DEP or a Town to review one and certainly
doesn't provide for the NJDEP to create a procedure for exemption which is what is being followed here, according to
NJDEP staff. I request a written copy of the policy that NJDEP staff has used in this case.

Here is the regulation:

(h) Special water resource protection areas shall be established along all
waters designated Category One at N.J.A.C. 7:9B and perennial or intermittent
streams that drain into or upstream of the Category One waters as shown on the USGS
Quadrangle Maps or in the County Soil Surveys, within the associated HUC 14 drainage.

Link: http://www.nj.gov/dep/rules/adoptions/2004_0202_watershed.pdf

Since this tributary to the Buckhorn is noted on the County Soil Survey map, it is therefore unjustifiable for the NJDEP
to invent such tools as aerial photography to second guess the status of this tributary.

With this in mind, please issue a correction letter to the applicant.

Sincerely,
Mike King, Chairperson
PRO

cc: Senator Leonard Lance
cc: Bill Wolfe, PEERS